Skip to main content

Brief History of Mechanics

Now if you are a structural engineer, you cannot go far in your life without dealing with mechanics. So I decided to put up an article regarding the very basic entities of mechanics, the objects one uses to relate the physical quantities to mathematics, namely scalars, vectors and tensors. I’ll begin by giving you a sense of what these English words mean in the realm of mechanics.

So, think of a guy beating another random person with his bat (I will let the readers decide if it was a cricket bat or a baseball one).  Now the guy getting beaten does not care where the punches are coming from; he is bound to be in bad shape at the end of it. All that he knows is how hard is he getting punched. This ladies and gentlemen is what we call scalar quantities. Now imagine the guy with a bat going on a cricket field (yes, I am an Indian so I’ll be prejudiced towards cricket). Now his strokes are measured in placement and power. Suddenly he wants to move his bat in a particular direction. So, this is what many of us are familiar with as vectors. Now imagine that the bat is now a hammer and the guy wants to hammer a nail on a surface. Also try to think that this nail for him is to hang his shirt. So now, along with power & direction, the orientation of the nail is also important. The guy will find a hard time hanging his clothes on a nail which is on the ceiling or the floor. So the same beating is now a tensor, where the magnitude, direction and the sense of orientation are equally important.

The story of scalars is pretty mundane if you ask a mechanics person. It’s more of a layman’s best shot at science. Every morning, you would hear swarms of people buzzing with the latest weather[dot]com temperature updates to try and sound cool. They do not know a thing about heat and heat transfer. But hey! Temperature is not a bad way to measure how ‘hot’ or ‘cold’ is it outside. In fact, that’s the first thing I personally check before stepping outside. But the thing is it has very little use in the more advanced science. So generally speaking, scalars are more of a newspaper quantity than a scientific one.

Vector is where most of the world lights up.  We all love vectors- be it the displacement, force or your favourite player’s (Sachin Tendulkar) shot. This is what has kept the world buzzing and afloat. But the sad part is that, the discussions of these quantities are often limited to classrooms. How often do you see the wind speed and if you do, when was the last time you noticed that there was direction alongside the number. How cool would it be if some guy jogging daily would check what the wind speed was and from which direction and then plan his course likewise. Vectors are here to stay and are soon going to be the next talking point among people. So if you have no idea regarding vectors go familiarize yourself with it.

In this race for popularity, Tensor is the sorry guy who is far lacking behind scalars and vectors. He is like the Royal Crown of United Kingdom, the ultimate formal executive authority but having virtually no say on political matters. It is a very obscure entity describing very specific quantities like stress and stuff. It is so uncommon that not even engineering undergraduate students are taught about it until their senior year. And the fact that it is often represented as a three by three array (matrix if you will) often makes me relate it to a tic-tac-toe game- tepid and boring. But, it is what most mechanicians feel, the ultimate tool to represent everything in the mechanics realm. So, if you are an unfortunate graduate student like me, you’ll find yourself stuck with it for most of the time.

Well, so much information even makes me confused. So let’s have a summary sort of, so to speak. Scalars while are very useful in your day-to-day purposes is pretty humdrum. Just imagine if you are a scalar person, then you are the ones in the mobs enjoying the fight. Vectors get a bit exiting. Imagine yourself as an audience to a spectacular match if you are a vectors’ fan. Tensor holds some what a sympathetic position. Being a tensor guy is like having the job of a carpenter superintendent. Not even the carpenter himself, who by the way has a pretty interesting job. 


  1. Darshan, Jinal, very interesting articles! I never knew you were so well informed about the structural behaviour! Keep it up! I will be reading and commenting on your posts regularly.

    1. Hello Professor. You have been the inspiration for us. It is very encouraging to know that one of the great structural engineering brain is our audience. We will appreciate any critical/complimentary comment that you might have for us. Once again thank you for your support.

    2. Yes, I completely agree with Darshan..!! The way you taught us was awesome, the painstaking efforts that you made in teaching RCC were always visible and we enjoyed each and every discussion with you. You and G.R.Vesmawala sir made sure we understand everything.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What is a Response Reduction factor?

In our previous blogs we discussed about  Response Spectrum Analysis ,  Earthquake and Energy Dissipation  as well as  Ductility demand in structures during seismic loading . In response spectrum analysis topics like mode shapes, modal mass participation factors, derivation of response spectrum we discussed. In earthquake vs energy dissipation blog, we talked about energy dissipated from buildings through strain energy, inelastic energy, hysteresis, damping and ductility. In ductility demand we discussed about importance of ductile detailing and how it helps a building to work during earthquakes just like a marathon runner during long runs.  Generally inelastic energy dissipation, damping energy, ductility demand and ductility capacity, hysteresis loops are all captured when a nonlinear model is built, and time history analysis is performed for the structure. But to do nonlinear time history analysis, it takes a long time to build a model. The performance evaluation and result ve

Ductility and Elasticity

Ductility and elasticity,the two most important terms that are discussed frequently in structural engineering. Elasticity defines about how much the material is elastic, that is to which extent the deformations are proportional to the forces applied on the material. While ductility defines the capability of the material to get itself stretched beyond the elastic zone. Let me explain this by taking a real life example. Take a two different material, a rubber band and a very thin steel or copper wire.  Pull the rubber with your hands by applying the force in exactly opposite direction, and force means a tiny amount of pull. You will notice that the mount of deformations caused by the small pull is very large, but when you leave the rubber band it will come back to it's original position. This means that the rubber band is elastic in nature. Oh, now you got something in your bucket. But wait, here comes the question. Till what magnitude of force can rubber band behave in such

Possible types of failures in a steel structure

We, structural engineers design all the members of a building, whether it might be a column, beam, a tie member or a strut anything, but we design it to resist certain forces. We predict a load, calculate forces in different members and design them member to resist a particular load. But sometimes because of some undetermined or unpredicted load the forced in certain members increase to a value which it cannot withstand and the LObmember fails. But what are the different possibilities of failure? How can a member fail? Don't worry, here is what we are going to talk about. The possible types of failures in steel structures. Steel is a ductile material and to build a structure using steel is like setting up a huge Jigsaw puzzle. You have 1000 different members and you need to connect them and tada..!! Your structure is up. But it is not as simple as it is visible. Steel being a very strong material  leads to slender members. Now you can imagine the difficulties associated with it