### Ductility and Elasticity

Ductility and elasticity,the two most important terms that are discussed frequently in structural engineering. Elasticity defines about how much the material is elastic, that is to which extent the deformations are proportional to the forces applied on the material. While ductility defines the capability of the material to get itself stretched beyond the elastic zone. Let me explain this by taking a real life example. Take a two different material, a rubber band and a very thin steel or copper wire.

Pull the rubber with your hands by applying the force in exactly opposite direction, and force means a tiny amount of pull. You will notice that the mount of deformations caused by the small pull is very large, but when you leave the rubber band it will come back to it's original position. This means that the rubber band is elastic in nature. Oh, now you got something in your bucket. But wait, here comes the question. Till what magnitude of force can rubber band behave in such a manner? The answer lies in your hands, you go on pulling the rubber till the rubber band gets hard enough to pull anymore, these deformations should be proportional to the magnitude of force that you applied. If you will go on pulling the rubber band then a stage will come that you need to apply very large force for any further deformations, and at certain point it suddenly breaks without any more deformations. This region beyond the elastic region is called as ductility of the material. Wait what?? Yes, it's the ductility. So now you should notice important aspect over here, the elasticity of the rubber band is good but the ductility is bad, so it is not necessary that the material which is elastic is always ductile.

"Oh gosh you broke the rubber band. Don't feel bad, we have one more material to test."

Take the thin steel or copper wire in your hands. Pull the wire hard using your hand or tie it from one end to a hook and pull it using your body. You need a lot of force to break this material. (In the initial stage you will argue that it takes a lot of force to stretch so how can it be elastic. Well the definition of elastic does not state that you require smaller force to strain the material, it states the behavior of material that when you deform it then it always has the tendency to come back to it's original shape.) You will observe that this material also behaves in an elastic manner, pull it, it will get deformed but when you free it, it will gain back it's original length. In case of this wire too there is a limit of applying the force, at a certain magnitude of pull you will start feeling that the material no longer requires any additional strength to deform. The amount of deformations goes on increasing at a constant level of force and it stretches like a plastic. It goes on and on and on. And at a certain stage it will break. Ah, you noticed the difference between the failure of a rubber band and the steel wire? Yes, after certain magnitude of load the wire has the tendency to stretch itself for a large amount of deformation as compared to a rubber band. This implies that the wire is both elastic as well as ductile.

Figure (a): Stress-strain curve of rubber band
Image Credits: Wikipedia

Figure (b): Stress strain curve of steel
Image Credits: Wikipedia

Notice the difference between two curves. Figure(a) shows the very little deformations in the rubber in the plastic zone. It describes that fact that in the end you require high force to break it but it breaks suddenly. While in case of figure(b) you will find that the material stretches itself up to a greater extent. The hump in the steel curve shows the ductile zone of the material. Video below shows the brittle nature of concrete and ductility of steel.

You learnt two things today, elasticity and ductility of the material. Now what about brittle material? You probably came to know by now that elasticity and ductility is all together different thing. Now the post elastic stage of a material is known as ductility or brittleness of material. Ductile material is like steel which you observed just above while a brittle material is glass. When you apply forces on glass it will resist it up to certain extent and it will suddenly fail without showing any large deformations. Bang and it's blown away. So the post elastic phase of the material defines the ductility or the brittleness of the material.

"That is why you have dents on the car's body but you can never find a dent in a glass or a concrete column."

Hope you will find this helpful in clearing the concepts of elasticity, ductility and brittleness of different materials. Next time we will concentrate on the properties of steel.

Fun Fact: Steel can be stretched up to 1.2 times it's original length.

Picture (a): Photograph of Rio-Antirrio bridge located in Greece. The foundations of the bridge are bigger than a football field. (We structural engineers always deal with great things.) The bridge has the longest span of 560 m and is one of the modern marvels of structural engineering. The height of the bridge from the soil bed is fucking 164 m. Image credits: Unknown

Good Bye, Have a nice day.

1. Simply Amazing !

1. Thanks.. Keep following the blog..:-D

2. Jinal, you will certainly make structural engineering popular in due course of time! Keep it up!!

1. Thank you Professor. I am really happy that you read this and gave a positive direction.

3. The images do not show up . i am viewing in mobile chrome browser on android os. Please take the necessary steps. And thanks for the great and easy explaination. I like viewing your site

4. Great way of explaining ductility and elasticity with examples.

5. You are truly amazingggg

6. Really helpful! I was taking elasticity and ductility as Same things but now everything is clear

7. Bright explanation. Many people still confusing elasticity and ductility.

8. Excellent Blog! I would like to thank for the efforts you have made in writing this post. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. I wanted to thank you for this websites!

### What is a Response Reduction factor?

In our previous blogs we discussed about  Response Spectrum Analysis ,  Earthquake and Energy Dissipation  as well as  Ductility demand in structures during seismic loading . In response spectrum analysis topics like mode shapes, modal mass participation factors, derivation of response spectrum we discussed. In earthquake vs energy dissipation blog, we talked about energy dissipated from buildings through strain energy, inelastic energy, hysteresis, damping and ductility. In ductility demand we discussed about importance of ductile detailing and how it helps a building to work during earthquakes just like a marathon runner during long runs.  Generally inelastic energy dissipation, damping energy, ductility demand and ductility capacity, hysteresis loops are all captured when a nonlinear model is built, and time history analysis is performed for the structure. But to do nonlinear time history analysis, it takes a long time to build a model. The performance evaluation and result ve

### Possible types of failures in a steel structure

We, structural engineers design all the members of a building, whether it might be a column, beam, a tie member or a strut anything, but we design it to resist certain forces. We predict a load, calculate forces in different members and design them member to resist a particular load. But sometimes because of some undetermined or unpredicted load the forced in certain members increase to a value which it cannot withstand and the LObmember fails. But what are the different possibilities of failure? How can a member fail? Don't worry, here is what we are going to talk about. The possible types of failures in steel structures. Steel is a ductile material and to build a structure using steel is like setting up a huge Jigsaw puzzle. You have 1000 different members and you need to connect them and tada..!! Your structure is up. But it is not as simple as it is visible. Steel being a very strong material  leads to slender members. Now you can imagine the difficulties associated with it